Nothing seemed to work this year at certain colleges, even wealth, legacy status or perfect scores. The phone has been ringing, and this is what people are saying:
1. "The college counselor told my son's friend that he shouldn't even apply to Stanford, and he got in. But nobody else did from his school, including the son of a big angel investor guy."
2. "Harvard was a big diss because she's not only a legacy, but someone who could absolutely do the work."
3. "He had off the chart scores and grades, and found out that he was 1/16 Mohegan, just in time to put it on his application. Got into Johns Hopkins, but waitlisted everywhere else."
4. "He never did anything interesting for summers, ever. But he got into Yale and a full scholarship at Annenberg."
5. "This is a kid who had 800s on everything, a debate champion and fourth or fifth generation at Princeton, he wasn't even waitlisted."
6. "In a four-hour period last Thursday she was shut out by four Ivies, as well as Williams and Tufts."
7. "I hope she likes Vassar well enough to stay on the wait list."
8. "He had over 790 on four SAT IIs, but was waitlisted at Harvard, Brown, Williams and Georgetown (which was her safety)."
9. "From our daughter's school, you need to play golf or water polo to get into Stanford."
10. "She was rejected, not even waitlisted, although she's written for TED and had a letter of recommendation from Arianna Huffington."
Depressing, right? Maybe not. According to top independent college counselor Kat Cohen, "While the admissions data can be intimidating, there is no need for students to panic. There are 3,700 colleges in the US, and more than 80 percent accept over half of their applicants. So while Harvard's 5.9 percent acceptance rate might seem discouraging, rest assured that there are literally hundreds of excellent schools you may never have heard of, which offer great opportunities to reach your academic and personal goals."
Wise words, Kat. But somehow I cannot imagine Harvard hopefuls ever reaching their personal goals – and those of their parents – at schools they have never heard of.